How to Fire an Employee Professionally

Firing someone is one of the parts of business ownership I don't think anyone looks forward to.

You're affecting someone's income.

Their routine.

Their confidence.

Potentially their family.

And when you are a small business owner, employees often aren't anonymous names on an organizational chart.

You know them.

You've trained them.

You've invested in them.

You've probably had conversations about their goals.

You may genuinely like them.

That can make termination incredibly difficult.

But I have also learned something equally important:

Avoiding a necessary termination can hurt everyone else in the business.

It can affect clients.

It can affect coworkers.

It can affect culture.

It can affect revenue.

It can affect your strongest employees.

And it can consume an enormous amount of the owner's time and energy.

I'm Erica Roybal, founder of Denver Dream Medspa and Colorado Aesthetics Academy.

Hiring and managing people has taught me that leadership is not only about encouraging people when they're doing well.

Sometimes leadership means having uncomfortable conversations.

Sometimes it means giving someone a real opportunity to improve.

And sometimes it means recognizing that the employment relationship is no longer working.

This is what I wish I understood earlier about handling performance problems—and letting someone go professionally when it becomes necessary.

This article reflects my experience as a business owner and is not legal or HR advice. Employment laws, contracts, protected leave, accommodations, discrimination protections, wage requirements, final-pay rules, unemployment issues, and termination procedures vary by jurisdiction and circumstances. Business owners should consult qualified employment counsel or HR professionals when appropriate.

The Biggest Mistake I Made as a Newer Leader: Waiting

I used to think being a good leader meant giving people more chances.

Then another chance.

Then explaining it differently.

Then waiting.

Then hoping.

Sometimes patience works.

People absolutely can improve.

Training matters.

Coaching matters.

People deserve clarity.

But eventually I learned:

More chances without meaningful change are not always kindness.

Sometimes they are avoidance.

I wasn't necessarily protecting the employee.

I was postponing a decision I didn't want to make.

Meanwhile, someone else was absorbing the consequences.

Performance Problems Rarely Affect Only the Owner

Suppose one employee repeatedly:

Shows up late.

Doesn't complete responsibilities.

Ignores procedures.

Creates client complaints.

Leaves work for coworkers.

Doesn't follow through.

Or refuses feedback.

The consequences spread.

The reliable employee picks up the work.

Reception handles the unhappy client.

Another provider stays late.

The manager repeats the same conversation.

The owner spends hours dealing with the issue.

Eventually your best employees start wondering:

Why am I working so hard when this is allowed?

That is when an individual performance problem becomes a culture problem.

Your Strongest Employees Are Watching What You Tolerate

This was an important leadership lesson for me.

Culture isn't only what you put in your employee handbook.

Culture is what employees see happen repeatedly.

If you say:

Reliability matters.

But chronic unreliability has no consequence, employees notice.

If you say:

Client safety comes first.

But serious safety concerns are repeatedly ignored, employees notice.

If you say:

Everyone is accountable.

But some people aren't, employees notice.

Your standards become believable when your decisions support them.

Before You Fire Someone, Ask Whether You Actually Led Them

This is the question I think every owner should ask.

Did this person clearly understand what was expected?

Sometimes what looks like employee failure is actually leadership failure.

Maybe:

The job description was vague.

Training was inconsistent.

Nobody explained the metric.

Different managers gave different instructions.

The employee never received feedback.

The system was broken.

The expectation changed without communication.

Before blaming the person, evaluate the environment you created.

Clear Expectations Come Before Accountability

You cannot fairly hold someone accountable to an expectation she never understood.

I want employees to know:

What their job is.

What success looks like.

What standards matter.

What metrics are being measured.

What policies apply.

Who they report to.

What happens when performance is below expectations.

Ambiguity creates frustration on both sides.

"You Need to Do Better" Is Not Useful Feedback

Better at what?

Be specific.

Instead of:

"Your performance isn't good."

A useful conversation might address:

Your rebooking has consistently fallen below the role's expectation.

There have been repeated attendance problems.

Treatment-room turnover is not being completed according to protocol.

Client documentation is incomplete.

Deadlines have repeatedly been missed.

Specific feedback gives someone something she can actually correct.

Separate the Person From the Performance

This is one of the ways I try to approach difficult conversations.

There is a difference between:

"You're irresponsible."

and:

"You've arrived late for four scheduled shifts this month."

One attacks identity.

The other addresses behavior.

You can hold someone accountable without humiliating her.

In fact, specific behavioral feedback is usually much stronger than emotional criticism.

Address Problems Early

Small problems are easier to correct than entrenched patterns.

If something concerns me, I would rather address it while it is:

One incident.

One missed expectation.

One communication problem.

Instead of waiting until I'm so frustrated that I have a list of 20 things.

Early feedback gives the employee a better opportunity to improve.

It also helps prevent resentment from building on the management side.

Don't Save Six Months of Frustration for One Conversation

If you're angry about something an employee has been doing for six months but you've never mentioned it, the employee may believe everything is fine.

Then suddenly:

"We're terminating you because of all these things you've done."

From the employee's perspective, that can feel completely unexpected.

Not every situation allows for progressive feedback, particularly when serious conduct or safety issues arise.

But for ordinary performance problems, I believe employees should generally understand where they stand.

Document Performance Problems

Documentation is one of those things owners sometimes avoid because it feels formal.

But documentation creates clarity.

Depending on the situation and your policies, records might include:

• Date

• Specific issue

• Relevant policy or expectation

• Previous discussions

• Employee response

• Expected correction

• Deadline

• Follow-up

• Outcome

Keep documentation factual.

Not emotional.

Bad Documentation Sounds Like This

"Sarah has a terrible attitude and doesn't care."

That is subjective.

Better documentation would describe what actually occurred.

For example:

"On [date], the employee was instructed to complete X by the end of the shift. At [time], the task remained incomplete. During the follow-up discussion, the employee stated..."

Facts are more useful than labels.

Do Not Write Documentation While You're Angry

This is something I think owners need to hear.

If you're furious:

Wait until you can write objectively.

Do not put emotional language into an employee record.

Do not exaggerate.

Do not speculate about motives.

Do not diagnose someone's personality.

Document:

What happened.

What was expected.

What was communicated.

What happens next.

Give Feedback in Real Time When Possible

If someone makes an error Tuesday, don't wait until a performance review three months later to mention it.

Especially if the issue involves:

Client care.

Sanitation.

Communication.

Safety.

Professionalism.

Correct it.

Explain why.

Document when appropriate.

Then watch whether the behavior changes.

Coaching Is Different From Repeating Yourself Forever

Good leaders coach.

But there is a point where coaching stops being coaching and becomes:

Repeating the same conversation.

If you've clearly explained the problem.

Provided training.

Set expectations.

Given reasonable time.

Followed up.

And the same issue continues...

The question changes.

It is no longer:

"Does she understand?"

It may become:

"Is she willing or able to meet this expectation?"

That distinction matters.

Skill Problems and Will Problems Are Different

I think about performance problems in two broad categories.

Skill

The person wants to do the job but doesn't yet know how.

This may improve through:

Training.

Practice.

Observation.

Resources.

Feedback.

Will

The person knows what is expected but repeatedly chooses not to do it.

This can show up as:

Ignoring procedures.

Refusing feedback.

Repeatedly failing to follow through.

Chronic lack of effort.

Those problems require different management responses.

You can train a skill gap.

It is much harder to train someone into caring.

Sometimes the Problem Is Role Fit

Not every termination means someone is a bad person or bad employee.

Sometimes:

The role requires more sales than she enjoys.

The pace is too fast.

The schedule doesn't fit.

She doesn't enjoy client-facing work.

The business needs more independence than she currently has.

Her strengths would be better used somewhere else.

That is not necessarily failure.

It may simply be a mismatch.

Sometimes You Made the Wrong Hire

Owners need accountability too.

Maybe you hired too quickly.

Ignored a red flag.

Did not define the role.

Hired because you liked the person.

Hired because you were desperate.

Hired for technical skill without evaluating professionalism.

If the hire was wrong, learn from it.

Do not keep the wrong person indefinitely because admitting the hiring mistake is uncomfortable.

Performance Improvement Plans Can Be Useful

For appropriate performance issues, a formal improvement plan can create structure.

A plan might identify:

The Problem

What specifically needs improvement?

The Standard

What is expected?

The Measurement

How will improvement be evaluated?

Support

What training or resources will be provided?

Timeline

When will progress be reviewed?

Consequences

What may happen if sufficient improvement does not occur?

The goal should not be creating paperwork simply to fire someone.

The goal should be clarity.

A Performance Plan Needs Measurable Expectations

Avoid:

"Improve attitude."

Instead, identify observable expectations.

Depending on the role, that could include:

Arrive ready for scheduled shifts by the required time.

Complete documentation before the end of each shift.

Follow sanitation protocol consistently.

Respond to assigned leads within the established timeframe.

Meet clearly communicated job-performance expectations.

Measurable expectations make follow-up much more productive.

Don't Create Impossible Improvement Plans

If you've already decided to fire someone, don't create an impossible plan just to manufacture a paper trail.

That isn't good leadership.

If you're giving someone an opportunity to improve, make it a real opportunity.

Set standards that are:

Relevant.

Reasonable.

Understandable.

Measurable.

Then evaluate honestly.

Safety Issues Are Different

In aesthetics, certain issues can carry much greater consequences.

Concerns involving things like:

• Serious sanitation failures

• Unsafe treatment practices

• Working outside permitted scope

• Falsification

• Client privacy

• Serious dishonesty

• Harassment

• Violence or threats

• Theft

• Impairment

• Other significant misconduct

may require a very different response from ordinary performance coaching.

Do not assume every issue needs three warnings.

Your policies, the facts, applicable law, and professional guidance matter.

Client and employee safety come first.

Sanitation Is Not a Personality Preference

This is particularly important in aesthetics.

If I correct:

Brand voice.

Room styling.

How a product is displayed.

there may be flexibility.

Sanitation is different.

If an item becomes contaminated, it is contaminated.

If a protocol exists for safety, following it is not optional because someone prefers another workflow.

Repeated safety problems can become serious very quickly.

Honesty Matters Enormously to Me

I can work with:

"I made a mistake."

I can work with:

"I didn't understand."

I can work with:

"I forgot."

What becomes much more difficult is:

Hiding.

Lying.

Changing the story.

Blaming someone else for something you know you did.

Trust is foundational in a workplace.

Once I begin questioning whether the information I'm receiving is truthful, the employment relationship becomes much harder to maintain.

Accountability Is One of the Most Important Qualities an Employee Can Have

The strongest response to a mistake is often:

"That was my mistake. I understand what happened. Here's what I'm doing differently."

That gives me something to work with.

Accountability creates improvement.

Defensiveness blocks it.

Do Not Confuse an Explanation With an Excuse

Context matters.

Employees have lives.

Emergencies happen.

Systems fail.

Miscommunication happens.

A good manager should listen.

But there is a difference between:

Understanding why something happened

and:

Removing responsibility for correcting a repeated pattern.

You can have compassion and still maintain a standard.

Compassion and Accountability Can Exist Together

I don't believe leadership needs to be cold.

You can care about an employee.

Understand that she is going through something.

Offer appropriate flexibility when possible.

And still say:

"This role requires X, and that expectation is not currently being met."

Compassion without boundaries can create chaos.

Accountability without humanity can create a terrible workplace.

Good leadership needs both.

Consistency Matters

If one employee receives consequences for something another employee routinely does without consequence, you can create serious culture problems and potentially legal risk.

Policies and performance standards should be applied thoughtfully and consistently.

That does not mean every situation is identical.

Facts differ.

Circumstances differ.

But decisions should have legitimate business reasons behind them.

Be Careful About Protected Issues

Before terminating someone, especially when the situation involves things like:

Medical issues.

Disability or accommodation requests.

Pregnancy.

Protected leave.

Workplace injury.

Complaints about harassment or discrimination.

Wage complaints.

Whistleblowing.

Protected activity.

Military obligations.

Or another legally protected circumstance...

Stop and get qualified advice when needed.

The fact that someone also has a performance issue does not eliminate employment-law considerations.

This is one of the areas where an owner should not guess.

Do Not Fire Someone in Anger

Even when you're furious.

Especially then.

A termination should be a business decision.

Not an emotional reaction.

If there is no immediate safety reason requiring action, make sure you understand:

What happened.

What documentation exists.

What policy applies.

Whether similar situations were handled consistently.

Whether legal review is appropriate.

Then make the decision.

Ask Yourself These Questions Before Termination

Before I conclude that an employment relationship should end, I would want to understand:

What specifically is the problem?

Has the expectation been clearly communicated?

Has the employee received appropriate training?

Has she had a reasonable opportunity to improve when appropriate?

Is the problem documented?

Has the same issue continued?

Is this affecting clients, coworkers, safety, revenue, or culture?

Are we applying standards consistently?

Is there a protected or legally sensitive issue involved?

Is there a realistic reason to believe more coaching will change the outcome?

That final question matters.

How I Know When I've Reached the End of Coaching

There isn't one universal formula.

But I become much more likely to consider termination when I see a repeated pattern of:

The same feedback.

The same problem.

The same conversation.

The same promise to change.

And no meaningful change.

At that point, continuing the cycle may not be helping anyone.

The Cost of Keeping the Wrong Employee Is Bigger Than Payroll

Owners often think:

"I can't afford to lose her right now."

But what is keeping her costing you?

Potential costs include:

• Lost clients

• Refunds

• Poor reviews

• Coworker frustration

• Management time

• Lower morale

• Overtime

• Rework

• Lost referrals

• Safety risk

• Reputation damage

The paycheck may not be the largest cost.

Your Best Employee May Leave Because You Won't Deal With Your Worst One

This is one of the hardest leadership lessons.

Strong employees usually have options.

If they repeatedly have to:

Cover shifts.

Fix mistakes.

Handle complaints.

Carry more work.

Watch standards go unenforced.

they may eventually decide:

Why am I still here?

Protecting your culture sometimes requires making difficult personnel decisions.

Don't Make the Rest of the Team Manage the Problem for You

Coworkers should not have to become unofficial supervisors because the owner avoids conflict.

If there is a performance problem:

Management should manage it.

Do not force the team to continually compensate for someone while you hope the issue resolves itself.

That breeds resentment.

The Termination Conversation Should Be Clear

When the decision has been made and appropriate review is complete, the termination conversation generally should not become a two-hour debate.

Communicate the decision clearly.

Something like:

"We've made the decision to end your employment effective today."

Then explain the relevant next steps.

Do not spend 20 minutes building up to the sentence.

Ambiguity increases anxiety.

Do Not Turn Termination Into a Character Assassination

You do not need to list every thing you have ever disliked about someone.

Address the decision professionally.

The goal is not:

To win.

To prove you were right.

To make the person feel bad.

The employment relationship is ending.

Handle it with dignity.

Do Not Argue About the Decision

The employee may disagree.

She may be upset.

She may explain.

Listen appropriately.

But if the final decision has been made, you generally do not need to turn the conversation into a negotiation.

Clarity is kinder than:

"Maybe... I don't know... we'll see..."

when you know the decision is final.

Keep the Meeting Private

Termination is not a team event.

Do not embarrass someone in front of coworkers.

Handle the conversation privately and professionally, while considering appropriate safety and HR practices for the circumstances.

People deserve dignity even when employment is ending.

Prepare the Logistics Before the Meeting

Before the conversation, know how you will handle applicable items such as:

• Final compensation

• Benefits information

• Company property

• Keys

• Access cards

• Devices

• Password/access changes

• Client records

• Confidential information

• Personal belongings

• Required notices

• Unemployment-related information where applicable

The exact requirements depend on jurisdiction and circumstances.

Do not improvise legal or payroll obligations in the room.

Protect Access Promptly

When someone leaves the company, review access to:

• Scheduling

• Email

• CRM

• Payment systems

• Social media

• Shared drives

• Client records

• Internal messaging

• Door codes

• Alarm systems

This is not about assuming the former employee will do something wrong.

It is basic operational security.

Client Information Needs to Stay Protected

Beauty and aesthetics businesses often hold significant client information.

Depending on the business, that may include:

Contact information.

Treatment records.

Photos.

Payment information.

Medical or health-related information.

Employees should understand from the beginning what information belongs to the business, what is confidential, and what they are authorized to access or use.

Do not wait until termination to think about data protection.

Do Not Publicly Explain Why Someone Was Fired

After termination, coworkers may ask:

"What happened?"

Clients may ask.

You generally do not need to share personnel details.

You can communicate operational information without turning a former employee's performance history into workplace gossip.

Protect professionalism on both sides.

What I Would Tell the Team

The exact message depends on the situation, but it can often be simple:

"[Name] is no longer with the company. We wish her well. Going forward, [operational information]."

Then explain:

Who is covering clients.

Who handles questions.

What schedule changes exist.

Keep the team focused on the transition.

Don't Let the Former Employee Become the Office's Entertainment

Gossip after a termination can damage culture.

Leaders set the tone.

If management begins sharing private details, employees learn that their own private issues may eventually become team conversation.

That destroys trust.

Handle Clients Carefully

If the employee had an established clientele, make the transition smooth.

Clients care about:

Who will see them?

Will their appointment change?

Will their treatment plan continue?

Who has their records?

How do they rebook?

The communication should focus on the client's continuity of service.

Not the employee's personnel history.

Do Not Make Clients Choose Sides

A client may genuinely like the departing provider.

That's okay.

Do not insult the former employee to preserve the client relationship.

Stay professional.

The way you behave during transitions says a lot about your company.

After the Termination, Review What Happened

Once the immediate situation is over, I think the owner should ask:

What did this teach us?

Was there a hiring red flag?

Was onboarding weak?

Were expectations unclear?

Did we wait too long?

Was compensation wrong?

Was the role poorly designed?

Did management avoid feedback?

Was the person simply the wrong fit?

Every difficult employment experience should improve the next hiring decision.

Update Your Interview Process

If the issue was:

Poor sanitation...

Strengthen the practical.

If it was:

Inability to receive feedback...

Give feedback during the interview and observe the response.

If it was:

Poor reliability...

Ask better behavioral questions and check references where appropriate.

If it was:

Overpromising clients...

Include consultation scenarios.

Turn experience into a better hiring system.

Update Your Onboarding Process

Sometimes a termination reveals a system gap.

Maybe nobody properly trained:

Documentation.

Opening procedures.

Closing procedures.

Client follow-up.

Sanitation.

Rebooking.

Complaint handling.

Fix the system so the next employee has a better chance of succeeding.

Do Not Immediately Assume You Need to Replace the Person

After someone leaves, owners often rush to post the position.

First ask:

Do we still need this role?

Maybe the business changed.

Maybe the work can be redistributed.

Maybe technology can solve part of it.

Maybe you need a different position entirely.

Maybe the previous role was poorly designed.

A vacancy is an opportunity to rethink the organization.

Sometimes Firing Someone Improves the Business Immediately

This can be uncomfortable to admit.

But sometimes after the wrong employee leaves:

The team relaxes.

Communication improves.

Complaints decrease.

Work gets completed.

Culture feels lighter.

That can be confirmation that the issue was affecting more people than you realized.

Sometimes You Will Still Feel Terrible

You can make the correct business decision and still feel bad about it.

Those things can coexist.

Terminating someone is not enjoyable simply because it is necessary.

You can care about the person and still believe the working relationship needs to end.

Leadership sometimes requires carrying both truths.

Do Not Let Guilt Become Your Management Strategy

This is something I had to learn.

If every decision is driven by:

"I feel bad."

eventually you stop managing the business.

Employees deserve compassion.

They also deserve competent leadership.

Clients deserve standards.

Your strong employees deserve fairness.

And the business deserves decisions that allow it to remain healthy.

Firing Someone Does Not Automatically Mean You Failed as a Leader

Sometimes you hired incorrectly.

Sometimes you trained poorly.

Own that when it happens.

But sometimes you:

Communicated.

Trained.

Supported.

Coached.

Documented.

Provided opportunities.

And the fit still didn't work.

Not every employment relationship will.

Leadership isn't measured by never losing an employee.

It is measured partly by how responsibly you handle the entire relationship.

The Goal Should Never Be to "Catch" Employees

I don't want a culture where management waits for people to fail.

I want employees to succeed.

I want clear expectations.

Useful feedback.

Training.

Opportunities.

Recognition.

Accountability.

The purpose of performance management should be improving performance.

Termination becomes relevant when that process is no longer producing a workable employment relationship—or when circumstances are serious enough that continued employment is inappropriate.

Praise Matters Too

If the only time an employee hears from you is when something is wrong, eventually feedback itself becomes threatening.

Recognize:

Great client experiences.

Strong production.

Improved rebooking.

Teamwork.

Reliability.

Excellent sanitation.

Initiative.

Growth.

Good leadership is not only correction.

People need to know what they should continue doing too.

Have Regular Performance Conversations Before There Is a Crisis

Do not wait for a major problem.

Depending on the business, review:

Performance.

Goals.

Metrics.

Training.

Challenges.

Client feedback.

Career growth.

Having regular conversations makes difficult feedback less surprising.

It also helps you identify problems earlier.

What I Would Track for an Esthetician Employee

Depending on the role, I may look at things like:

• Attendance

• Service revenue

• Average ticket

• Schedule utilization

• Rebooking

• Retention

• Retail

• Membership performance where applicable

• Client feedback

• Complaints

• Sanitation

• Documentation

• Team contribution

• Professional development

No single metric tells the whole story.

Context matters.

Low Revenue Alone Doesn't Always Mean Someone Should Be Fired

Maybe:

The provider is new.

The business isn't generating enough leads.

Her schedule is poor.

She wasn't trained to rebook.

Marketing is weak.

Demand is seasonal.

You need to determine whether the problem is:

Provider performance

or:

Business performance.

Owners need accountability too.

Don't Blame an Employee for an Empty Schedule You Didn't Help Create

If you hire someone with no clientele and promise opportunity, then provide:

No marketing.

No leads.

No visibility.

No training.

No strategy.

it is unfair to act surprised when her schedule is empty.

Providers should participate in building clientele.

The business also needs to fulfill whatever role it represented it would play.

On the Other Hand, Employees Need Ownership Too

If the business provides:

Leads.

Website traffic.

Advertising.

Existing clients.

Brand reputation.

Training.

Content opportunities.

Referral systems.

and the provider still refuses to:

Follow up.

Create content.

Ask for rebooking.

Build relationships.

Learn.

then that matters too.

Building a clientele is usually a shared effort.

Performance Problems Should Become More Specific, Not More Emotional

As frustration increases, owners sometimes say:

"You just don't care."

Maybe.

But prove the performance issue with facts.

Instead:

Three assigned client follow-ups were not completed.

The room was left unprepared on four documented occasions.

Rebooking expectations were discussed on these dates and the agreed actions were not completed.

Specificity protects everyone.

What I Would Include in a Performance Conversation

For a typical correctable issue, I want to cover:

1. What happened?

Specific facts.

2. Why does it matter?

Client, team, safety, revenue, or operations.

3. What is expected?

Clear standard.

4. What support is available?

Training, resources, clarification.

5. When will we review it?

Timeline.

6. What happens if it does not improve?

Clear consequence where appropriate.

Then document the conversation consistently with your policies.

Signs It May Be Time to Stop Coaching

Every situation is different, but I become concerned when I see:

• Repeated violation of the same expectation

• No meaningful improvement after clear feedback

• Dishonesty

• Serious safety concerns

• Chronic unreliability

• Persistent refusal to follow procedures

• Consistent defensiveness

• Repeated client complaints with no behavior change

• Negative impact on the team

• Lack of accountability

• Continued poor performance despite appropriate support

At some point, continuing employment may stop being fair to the rest of the organization.

My Rule for Difficult Employee Decisions

I try to ask:

Am I avoiding this decision because I genuinely believe the person can improve—or because I don't want to have an uncomfortable conversation?

Those are very different reasons to wait.

That question has helped me become a better leader.

Frequently Asked Questions About Firing an Employee

When should you fire an employee?

There is no universal threshold. Serious misconduct or safety issues may require immediate action, while ordinary performance problems may warrant coaching and an opportunity to improve. Consider the facts, your policies, prior communication, documentation, applicable employment law, and professional advice.

How many warnings should an employee receive before termination?

There is no universal number that applies to every employer or situation. Company policies, contracts, applicable law, seriousness of conduct, and prior history all matter. Do not assume a "three strikes" rule is legally required or appropriate.

Should I give an employee a performance improvement plan before firing them?

A performance improvement plan can be useful for correctable performance problems, but it is not appropriate or legally required in every situation. Use it when there is a genuine opportunity for improvement and consult qualified professionals when needed.

What should I document before firing an employee?

Document relevant facts, expectations, prior feedback, training or support, policy issues, employee responses, follow-up, and outcomes as appropriate. Keep records objective and consistent with your HR practices and applicable law.

Can I fire an employee for poor performance?

Poor performance can be a legitimate business concern, but termination decisions can involve legal considerations. Make sure expectations were clear, facts are documented appropriately, policies are applied consistently, and no protected legal issue is being overlooked.

Should I fire someone immediately for a sanitation violation?

It depends on the severity, circumstances, policies, training, prior history, and applicable requirements. Some safety violations may warrant serious or immediate action. Others may be appropriate for correction and retraining. Evaluate the actual risk rather than using a universal rule.

How do I fire someone without being cruel?

Be clear, private, respectful, and concise. Do not humiliate the person, argue unnecessarily, gossip afterward, or turn the meeting into a list of personal criticisms.

What should I say when firing someone?

Once the decision is final, clarity is usually best. State that the employment relationship is ending and explain the necessary next steps. Your exact wording and procedures should be appropriate to your policies, jurisdiction, and circumstances.

Should I tell the team why someone was fired?

Generally, employees do not need another employee's private performance details. Communicate what the team needs to know operationally while respecting confidentiality and professionalism.

What if the employee gets angry?

Plan ahead. Keep the conversation professional, consider appropriate safety measures based on the circumstances, and avoid escalating an argument. If you anticipate a significant safety concern, seek appropriate professional guidance before the meeting.

What if I feel guilty after firing someone?

Feeling bad does not automatically mean the decision was wrong. Review whether the employee received clarity, support, appropriate opportunities to improve, and a professional process. Learn from the experience and improve your management systems.

My Employee Performance Checklist Before Termination

For an ordinary performance problem, I would want to be able to answer:

Is the expectation clear?

Was the employee trained appropriately?

Have I explained the problem specifically?

Have I documented relevant issues?

Has the employee had an appropriate opportunity to improve?

Did I provide useful feedback?

Did I follow up?

Has the behavior changed?

Is the problem affecting clients, safety, coworkers, finances, or culture?

Have similar situations been treated consistently?

Is there any legally protected issue I need professional advice about?

Do I genuinely believe more coaching will change the outcome?

If that final answer is repeatedly:

No.

I need to stop pretending another conversation will necessarily solve it.

What I Wish I Knew About Leadership Earlier

I used to think leadership meant:

Helping.

Teaching.

Encouraging.

Giving opportunities.

It does.

But leadership also means:

Setting standards.

Having difficult conversations.

Documenting problems.

Protecting clients.

Protecting the team.

Making decisions.

And sometimes saying:

This isn't working anymore.

That does not make you heartless.

How you handle it determines what kind of leader you are.

The Standard I Try to Hold Myself To

Before I let someone go, I want to know that I was fair.

Not perfect.

Fair.

Did I communicate?

Did I listen?

Did I train?

Did I clarify?

Did I give feedback?

Did I address the problem rather than the person's character?

Did I give a real opportunity to improve when appropriate?

Did I protect the business?

And when it became clear the relationship wasn't working, did I have the courage to make the decision?

That is the standard.

Sometimes the Kindest Answer Is Clarity

Keeping someone in a role where she is continually failing isn't necessarily compassionate.

She knows there is tension.

You know there is tension.

The team knows.

The client may know.

Sometimes ending the relationship allows both sides to move forward.

The employee may find a position that fits her strengths better.

The business can rebuild the role.

And the team can regain stability.

Not every ending has to become a war.

My Advice to the Business Owner Who Knows Someone Needs to Go

Do not fire someone impulsively.

Do not fire someone because you're angry.

Do not ignore employment law.

Do not skip documentation because you're uncomfortable.

Do not humiliate someone.

But also:

Do not allow fear of an uncomfortable conversation to become your management strategy.

If you've communicated.

Supported.

Trained.

Documented.

Followed up.

And the same serious performance problem continues...

you eventually have to make a decision.

Your responsibility is not only to one employee.

It is also to:

Your clients.

Your students.

Your team.

Your business.

Your family.

And yourself.

Leadership means considering all of them.

— Erica Roybal

Continue Reading

What I Look for When Hiring an Esthetician

The best termination strategy starts with making better hiring decisions.

[READ: WHAT I LOOK FOR WHEN HIRING AN ESTHETICIAN →]

How to Know When It's Time to Hire Your First Employee

Before you add payroll, make sure demand, cash flow, utilization, systems, and management capacity support the decision.

[READ: WHEN TO HIRE YOUR FIRST EMPLOYEE →]

Revenue Is Not Profit

Learn how payroll, utilization, margins, provider production, and cash flow affect the financial health of your business.

[READ: REVENUE IS NOT PROFIT →]

What I Wish I Knew Before Opening a Med Spa

The lessons I've learned about people, equipment, marketing, money, operations, and becoming an owner.

[READ THE MED SPA OWNER GUIDE →]

How to Get Your First Esthetician Job

If you're on the other side of the hiring table, learn what can help a new esthetician stand out.

[READ THE FIRST ESTHETICIAN JOB GUIDE →]

How I Built My Esthetics Businesses While Raising My Son

The personal story behind my businesses and how motherhood changed how I think about leadership, ambition, and success.

[READ MY STORY →]

This article is educational and reflects Erica's experience as a business owner. It is not legal, employment, HR, tax, or financial advice. Employment decisions can involve complex federal, state, and local requirements. Consult qualified professionals about your specific circumstances.